Myth
Published: 15. 5. 2025
Understanding BIO, Organic, and Natural Claims in Cosmetics
Why “natural” doesn’t always mean safer, and how cosmetics laws protect consumers.
The Regulatory Landscape for Cosmetics
Each Country Has Its Own Rules
Cosmetics are tightly regulated around the world. In the European Union, the EU Cosmetics Regulation (EC) No 1223/2009 sets strict standards for product safety, labeling, and ingredient use. In the United States, the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) monitors cosmetics under the Federal Food, Drug, and Cosmetic Act. Many other countries have comparable laws, often shaped by similar scientific and public health considerations.
Evolving Lists of Allowed and Banned Ingredients
Regulatory bodies continuously update the list of approved and banned substances based on new scientific data. For instance, certain ingredients once deemed safe may be restricted or prohibited if new research shows a potential health risk. Conversely, some banned cosmetic ingredients might still be allowed in pharmaceuticals (e.g., ketoconazole in medicinal shampoos, lidocaine in topical anesthetics) because the intended use, dosage, and safety profile differ significantly between cosmetics and drugs.
Legal Baseline Ensures Safety
When an ingredient is approved for use in a cosmetic product, it has undergone assessment for its concentration, mode of application, and effects on human health. This means that if a product is legally sold on the market and complies with all regulations, it is considered safe for the intended use. Assigning “danger levels” to legally compliant ingredients can be misleading because the very premise of cosmetic regulation is to ensure the safety of consumers.
BIO, Organic, and Natural Claims, what do they mean?
Labels such as “BIO,” “Organic,” or “Natural” suggest more stringent requirements than those mandated by law. These standards are typically established by third-party certification bodies or industry groups (e.g., ECOCERT, COSMOS, Soil Association) or federal program USDA Organic. They define specific criteria regarding ingredient sourcing, processing methods, and environmental impact.
BIO/Organic: Usually refers to products containing ingredients grown without synthetic pesticides or fertilizers. Third-party certifications may require a certain percentage of organic ingredients and ban certain chemical processes.
Natural: Generally indicates that ingredients are sourced from nature rather than made synthetically. However, the terms “100% natural” or “made with natural ingredients” can vary in meaning, since different certification organizations have different thresholds and processing allowances.
Are “Natural” and “Organic” Products Safer?
Not necessarily. Many consumers equate “natural” with “safe,” but natural ingredients can be powerful allergens or irritants. Think of common allergens like pollen, essential oils, or botanical extracts, these are completely natural but can cause strong reactions in sensitive individuals.
Marketing vs. Reality
These claims (BIO, Organic, Natural) often serve as marketing tools to appeal to specific consumer preferences, like environmental consciousness or a desire to avoid synthetic chemicals. While they can guide consumers to products that align with personal values, they do not inherently guarantee a safer product compared to a legally compliant conventional cosmetic.
The Importance of Perspective: Focus on What Matters
Navigating Negative Headlines
It’s easy to get caught up in stories labeling certain ingredients as “toxic” or “harmful.” However, cosmetic safety laws already consider maximum usage limits, exposure levels, and scientific research. If an ingredient has been cleared for cosmetic use within those limits, it’s deemed safe for the general population.
Cosmetics Are Tools
Cosmetics exist to prevent or address specific problems, be it dry skin, acne, or signs of aging. Instead of searching obsessively for “bad” ingredients, consider the product’s intended benefit and your individual needs. Ask yourself:
- Does the product help my skin/hair concerns?
- Am I aware of any allergies or sensitivities I have?
- Is the product legally compliant and from a reputable brand?
Customizing to Individual Needs
Everyone’s skin and hair respond differently. While a certain natural extract might be a superhero ingredient for one person, it could cause irritation for another. Conversely, a synthetic compound designed to be hypoallergenic might be the safer choice for someone with sensitive skin.
Key Takeaways for Informed Consumers
- If a product adheres to national or regional regulations, it has passed safety assessments.
- “BIO,” “Organic,” and “Natural” are voluntary, above-the-Law standards guided by third-party rules that often focus on environmental impact, farming practices, and processing methods, rather than intrinsic safety.
Natural ≠ Safe
Nature can be potent; many allergens are plant-based. Pay attention to your personal sensitivities.
Regulations Evolve
Ingredient lists are regularly updated as new studies emerge. Regulators remove or restrict ingredients that pose a proven risk.
Choose Products Based on Your Needs
Look at the product’s benefits, your specific concerns, and potential allergies. Don’t just chase “clean” labels.
Final Thoughts
In the end, cosmetic law exists to safeguard consumer health. Although labels like “BIO,” “Organic,” and “Natural” suggest higher standards, every legally compliant cosmetic product, whether conventional or organically certified, undergoes rigorous scrutiny before hitting the market. Rather than getting tangled in the fear of “bad” ingredients, focus on finding products that best address your personal needs and preferences. With transparent labeling and ever-evolving science, consumers can feel assured that the core foundation of cosmetic regulations is to keep them safe.
Surfactants analysis
Relative assumption of treachery based on composition
Benefits by molecular size
From surface protection to deep moisturizing effects
Patented complexes
Identification of proven combinations with guaranteed effects
Order effect
Verification of the effective ratio of substances present in the composition
Join Us
Sign up for exclusive offers and the latest updates
Blog
© 2025 Cosminex
Cookies
We respect your privacy and allow you to choose which types of cookies you consent to for the best possible experience